Standing. A plaintiff has to plausibly show a real plan to come back to your website. In 2022 the Second Circuit, the federal appeals court that covers New York, upheld the dismissal of five ADA cases because the plaintiffs’ statements that they would return were boilerplate (Calcano v. Swarovski North America). Usher complaints are written with that decision in mind: a named product, dates and a reason. That makes standing harder to win on the papers, but those same details can be tested, especially when the same plaintiff filed five lawsuits on the same day. More: what standing means in an ADA lawsuit.
Websites with no store behind them. The complaint we read says the case is about the website alone, not a physical store. New York federal judges disagree about whether the ADA covers a website with no physical location, and the Second Circuit hasn’t decided. In December 2025 a Manhattan federal judge held that the ADA does not cover standalone websites, dismissed the federal claim, and left the state and city claims to be refiled in state court (Fernandez v. Gainful Health). Other judges in the same courthouse have ruled the other way, so this is a real argument, not a sure one. More: does the ADA apply to an online-only business?
Whether New York is the right place. Many of the companies sued are based in other states. A New York court needs a legal basis to hear a case against an out-of-state company, and selling to New York customers through the website is usually what the plaintiff relies on. In a 2019 Manhattan decision, the court found it had no jurisdiction over a grocery chain with no New York stores or deliveries (Diaz v. The Kroger Co.). More: sued in New York as an out-of-state business.
Fixing the four items, and proving it. Because the complaint names specific barriers, your developer can check each one. Manhattan federal judges have dismissed website cases as moot where the business documented its fixes and committed to keeping the site accessible, and have refused where the fixes were incomplete or only promised. Fixing the site doesn’t automatically end the state and city money claims. More: fix your website before or after you respond?
What the money claims are really worth. The federal ADA claim can’t produce money damages for the plaintiff, only an order to fix the site plus attorney’s fees. The damages come from the state and city claims, and what they are realistically worth in your case is one of the first things to work out. Published industry estimates put most small-business website settlements between $5,000 and $20,000 before legal fees, and New York cases often run higher. More: what it costs to settle an ADA website case.