ADA Website Lawsuit in New York State Supreme Court? What Is Different

Why your papers say Supreme Court, and the date that matters

By Michael Samuel, ADA defense attorney in New York

Steps and columns of the Manhattan state courthouse

If the summons you were served says “Supreme Court of the State of New York” and the complaint says your website can’t be used by a blind customer, your case is part of a shift. Since July 2026, four law firms alone have filed about 300 of these lawsuits in New York’s state courts instead of federal court: Mizrahi Kroub (197), Shaked Law Group (56), KSS Law (28) and Equal Access Law Group (21), according to our ADA lawsuit tracker, which is built from the public court records and was last counted for this article on November 15, 2026.

In New York, the Supreme Court is the main trial court in each county, not the highest court in the state. Most of these cases are in New York County (Manhattan) and the Bronx, with others in Brooklyn, Queens, Westchester and Staten Island.

People call these “ADA lawsuits,” and the federal version is one. The state court version usually isn’t, and that changes your deadline, your options and where the money claims come from.

The date that matters. In state court you generally have 20 days to respond if the summons was handed to you personally, and 30 days if it was served another way, such as through the New York Secretary of State. Write down how and when the papers reached you, and keep the envelope.

What a state court complaint claims

Calculator, pen and papers on a desk

Usually no federal claim at all. The state court website complaints we have defended sue under three New York laws: the New York State Human Rights Law, the New York City Human Rights Law and the New York Civil Rights Law. Many leave out the federal ADA entirely.

Why that matters: money. Under the federal ADA a private plaintiff can get an order to fix the site plus attorney’s fees, but no money damages. The state and city laws allow damages, and the Civil Rights Law adds a penalty of $100 to $500 for each violation. So a state court complaint is a money claim from the first page. More: why an ADA lawsuit asks for money.

The cap on the demand. A Mizrahi Kroub complaint we reviewed, filed in New York County in August 2026, states that the plaintiff’s total recovery, including damages, attorney’s fees and costs, will not exceed $74,999. Court filing summaries of the firm’s November 2026 cases list similar figures. That isn’t what these cases settle for. The number matters for a different reason, explained below: a case has to involve more than $75,000 before it can be moved to federal court on the ground that the parties are from different states.

The same screen reader story. The facts read like the federal complaints: a blind or visually impaired plaintiff, screen reading software, images without text descriptions, and menus or checkout steps that can’t be completed. For a walk-through, see how to read an ADA lawsuit complaint.

Your deadline, and how defaults happen

Hand circling a date on a calendar in red

20 days or 30 days. New York’s rules give you 20 days after the summons is personally delivered to you. If it was served another way, including delivery to the Secretary of State, you have 30 days after service is complete. You respond by serving an answer, or by making a motion to dismiss, which extends your time to answer.

The Secretary of State trap. A corporation or LLC registered in New York can be served by delivering the papers to the Secretary of State. Under the Business Corporation Law, service on a corporation is complete at that moment, and the rule for LLCs works the same way. The Secretary then sends the papers to the address the company has on file. If that address is an old office or a former lawyer, the papers may reach you late or not at all, while the clock runs.

A company can’t answer on its own. In New York courts a corporation or LLC has to appear through a lawyer. An owner can’t file the company’s answer personally.

What a default looks like. If you don’t respond, the plaintiff can ask for a default judgment. Before a judgment is entered against a corporation that was served through the Secretary of State, the plaintiff has to mail an additional copy of the summons to the company’s last known address at least 20 days ahead. If that extra mailing reaches you, treat it as the last warning. A plaintiff who waits more than a year after the default to seek judgment risks having the complaint dismissed as abandoned.

If a judgment was already entered. New York law gives two main routes to reopen a default. A court can excuse a default for a good reason if you move within one year after you are served with the judgment and notice of its entry. And a company that wasn’t personally served and didn’t get notice in time to defend can ask to reopen the case within one year of learning of the judgment, and no more than five years after it was entered, if it has a real defense. Both take a motion, and both get harder with every week of delay.

Can the case be moved to federal court?

Foley Square with two courthouses in view

Usually not, and it is worth understanding why before you spend money trying.

No federal claim, no automatic federal case. A case can be moved (“removed”) to federal court when it includes a claim under federal law. A complaint that sues only under New York State and City law doesn’t.

The other route needs more than $75,000. A state law case can also be removed when the plaintiff and the defendant are from different states and more than $75,000 is at stake. A complaint that limits the plaintiff’s recovery to $74,999 stays under that line. A defendant based in New York generally can’t use this route at all. And a notice of removal has to be filed within 30 days of being served, so there is no time to wait and see.

Federal judges have been sending these claims back anyway. In December 2025 a Manhattan federal judge dismissed the federal ADA claim against an online-only business and declined to keep the state and city claims, leaving them to be refiled in state court (Fernandez v. Gainful Health). Decisions like that are part of why plaintiffs’ firms now start in state court.

So the practical plan for most businesses is to defend the case where it was filed.

Defenses that have worked in state court

Shop owner and lawyer reviewing a laptop at the counter

State court is not friendlier to these complaints than federal court. Three recent decisions from New York County Supreme Court, all in cases this firm defended, show how.

  • Sumlin v. Royal Batch (June 15, 2026). The plaintiff said he couldn’t buy from a website with a screen reader and sued under the State and City Human Rights Laws and the Civil Rights Law. The court took notice that he had filed 36 nearly identical lawsuits in eighteen months, adopted the reasoning of the Second Circuit’s Calcano decision on standing, and found his standing allegations to be “bare legal conclusions or inherently incredible.” It also held that he had never asked the business for an accommodation, and that a website can’t be both the place of public accommodation and the policy that harms the plaintiff. The complaint was dismissed and leave to amend was denied.
  • Alexandria v. Just Shades, Inc. (July 11, 2026). A plaintiff who, by the defendant’s count, had filed 54 largely identical lawsuits sued a Manhattan retailer under the same three laws. The court dismissed the whole complaint and refused leave to amend. It held that the plaintiff never asked the business for an accommodation, that a notice sent to the Attorney General isn’t a request to the business, and that website design flaws aren’t a “policy or practice.” The court relied on the Sumlin decision.
  • Carrico v. Homelement, LLC (October 22, 2026). In a case brought by Mizrahi Kroub, the defendant moved to dismiss, the plaintiff didn’t oppose the motion, and the court dismissed the complaint and directed judgment for the defendant with costs.

The decisions, with their index numbers, are on our results page. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. These are trial court decisions. Other judges may see the same arguments differently, and New York’s appeals courts haven’t settled these questions.

Other defenses depend on your facts: whether a New York court has jurisdiction over an out-of-state company (see sued in New York as an out-of-state business), whether notice of the Civil Rights Law claim was served on the Attorney General, which that law requires at or before the start of the case, and whether the barriers in the complaint exist on your site at all.

How The Samuel Law Firm can help

Michael Samuel

Michael Samuel has defended about 100 ADA cases since 2019, most of them about websites, in New York state court and in the federal courts in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Three of the firm’s four written dismissals since March 2025 came in New York Supreme Court. Website cases are handled for a flat fee that covers all the work up to trial, including a motion to dismiss.

When a state court complaint comes in, we check how and when you were served and whether a default is already running, read the complaint against your website, look up the plaintiff’s other lawsuits, and decide whether to answer or move to dismiss. Then we tell you what a defense looks like and what a realistic resolution looks like, before you decide anything.

Call (212) 563-9884 before your deadline, or upload the complaint to our free complaint checker for a plain-English summary first. Firms that file in state court and that we have written about: Mizrahi Kroub, Shaked Law Group, KSS Law and Equal Access Law Group.

Frequently asked questions

Generally 20 days if the summons was delivered to you personally, and 30 days after service is complete if it was served another way, such as through the Secretary of State. Have a lawyer confirm the exact date right away, because missing it can lead to a default judgment.

Often not, strictly speaking. Many state court complaints leave out the federal ADA and sue under the New York State Human Rights Law, the New York City Human Rights Law and the New York Civil Rights Law. Those laws allow money damages, which the federal ADA doesn’t.

Usually not. A complaint with only state and city law claims can be removed only if the parties are from different states and more than $75,000 is at stake, and a defendant based in New York generally can’t remove on that ground. A notice of removal must be filed within 30 days of being served.

A New York corporation or LLC can be served through the Secretary of State, and service is complete when the Secretary receives the papers. If your address on file is out of date, the papers may never reach you. New York law lets a court reopen a default in that situation if you act promptly and have a real defense.

No. In New York courts a corporation or LLC has to appear through a lawyer. A person who is sued individually can answer for himself or herself, but not for the company.

Some do. New York County judges have dismissed website complaints for lack of standing, adopting the reasoning of the Second Circuit’s Calcano decision, and for failing to state a claim under the state and city laws. These are trial court decisions, and the outcome depends on the judge and the facts.

Talk it through

Free consultation, flat fee quoted before you commit

I am Michael Samuel. I have practiced law in New York since 1993 and I have handled roughly a hundred ADA accessibility matters, most of them website cases, for the business on the receiving end. If a letter or a lawsuit about your website has arrived, the first call costs nothing and you will get a straight answer about where you stand. I handle website accessibility defense on a flat fee, quoted before you commit, so you know the number up front.

Recent decisions in these cases, with the courts and index numbers, are on my results page. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. If your letter came from a firm we have written about, see what to know about Equal Access Law Group letters and what to know about Apex Trial Law letters.

For a free consultation, call 212-563-9884, email michael@thesamuellawfirm.com, or use the contact form.

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information about New York law and is not legal advice about your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship.


The Samuel Law Firm
1441 Broadway, Suite 6085
New York, NY 10018
212-563-9884

Contact Us

Sued, owed wages, or injured? Talk to a New York litigator today.

The Samuel Law Firm is a litigation firm in Manhattan. Michael Samuel defends businesses in ADA lawsuits, website and premises, in wage and hour cases, and in contract and commercial disputes, and represents employees owed wages and people injured by negligence. He has practiced in New York since 1993 and appears in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York and the New York state courts. Call 212-563-9884 for a free consultation; he answers directly