The amount. In the December 2025 case, the judge found the owner liable but refused to award the $341,022 the funder demanded, because the funder’s own payment history showed a balance of $246,072 and it never explained the difference. Check every number in the complaint against your bank statements.
Default fees. In the April 2025 case, the court excluded a $10,000 default fee as a penalty the funder hadn’t justified. A Monroe County judge struck BizFund’s default fee as a penalty in 2025 and again in 2026. More in Sued by BizFund?
What actually happened to the business. The guarantee is aimed at a breach, not a bad month. If sales really fell and the debits failed because the money wasn’t there, that is different from blocking the funder’s access or moving your deposits to a new account. Courts that uphold these agreements as purchases of future sales, and not loans, point to that same feature: repayment depends on your sales. Your bank records are the evidence.
Reconciliation, in writing. Most agreements let you ask the funder to lower the payments when sales drop. In the April 2025 case the owner said he had asked, but the contract required the request in writing and he had no record of one, so it didn’t help him. If you asked for a reconciliation, find the emails and whatever you sent with them.
Whether it is really a loan. If the agreement works like a loan, with a fixed term and no real way to adjust the payments, New York’s usury laws may apply. It is a hard defense, and courts reject it more often than they accept it. More: merchant cash advance lawsuit in New York.
Service and jurisdiction. You have to be served properly, and so does the company. If you live outside New York, the funder is relying on a clause in the agreement that chooses New York courts. More: sued in New York as an out-of-state business.