Sued Over Wage Notices and Pay Stubs in New York? What Those Claims Are Worth

Why your wage lawsuit includes a paperwork claim

By Michael Samuel, New York litigator

Bakery owner reading papers behind the counter

If your business has been sued for unpaid wages or overtime in New York, the complaint almost certainly has a second kind of claim mixed in with the pay claims. It says you didn’t give the worker the paperwork New York requires: a written pay notice when they were hired, and a proper wage statement (a pay stub) with every paycheck.

Those claims come from section 195 of the New York Labor Law, which applies to every employer in the state. They matter because they carry their own money, separate from any unpaid wages, and because they are in the complaint whether or not the worker was actually underpaid.

The date that matters. If the case is in federal court, you generally have 21 days after you are served to respond. If it is in New York State Supreme Court, it is generally 20 days if the papers were handed to you personally and 30 days if they were served another way. Write down the date and keep every page.

What the law allows for missing notices and pay stubs

Stack of pay stubs held by a binder clip

Section 198 of the Labor Law sets the amounts:

  • The hiring notice. $50 for each work day the notice was missing, up to a total of $5,000 per worker.
  • Wage statements. $250 for each work day the worker didn’t get a proper statement, up to a total of $5,000 per worker.
  • Attorney’s fees and costs on top of both.

So for each worker who sues, these two claims can add up to $10,000 before a single hour of unpaid wages is counted. In a case brought for a group of workers, the number grows with every person who joins.

The defense written into the law. The same section gives employers a defense to both claims if the employer made complete and timely payment of all wages due to the worker, or reasonably believed in good faith that the notice or statement wasn’t required. That makes your payroll records important twice: once for the wage claims and again for the paperwork claims.

The 2024 Guthrie decision: what it changed

Federal courthouse tower in Lower Manhattan

On August 30, 2024, the Second Circuit, the federal appeals court that covers New York, decided Guthrie v. Rainbow Fencing Inc. A Brooklyn welder had won a default judgment for his unpaid overtime, but the trial court refused to award him anything for the missing wage notices and statements. The appeals court agreed.

Its rule: in federal court, a worker can’t collect these statutory damages for a “technical violation” alone. The worker has to plausibly show that not getting the paperwork caused a real, concrete harm, for example that he would have spoken up and avoided being underpaid if he had the notice. The welder’s complaint didn’t say that, so the claim failed even though his employer never showed up to defend.

That doesn’t make the claims disappear. Federal judges have accepted complaints that tie the missing paperwork to a concrete loss. In one case the appeals court cited, a worker said her pay stubs showed fewer hours than she actually worked, which kept her from figuring out and demanding the wages she was owed. So the question in your case is what the complaint actually says, not just whether the words “wage notice” appear in it.

Where the claims can still cost you

Restaurant kitchen staff preparing food

Complaints written after Guthrie. Plaintiffs’ lawyers know the decision. Newer complaints often add a sentence or two explaining how the missing paperwork hurt the worker. Whether those sentences are specific enough is a fair fight, and it is usually raised at the start of the case.

State court. Guthrie is about what it takes to be in federal court. It doesn’t decide the question for New York’s state courts, and these claims can be brought there.

Defaults. A business that doesn’t respond gives up the chance to make any of these arguments. Even in Guthrie, the employer was hit with a default judgment for the unpaid wages.

When the wages really were short. The statutory defense depends on complete and timely payment. If the wage claims have merit, the paperwork claims are harder to knock out, and both become part of the settlement math.

More on how a case like this unfolds, from the first days through settlement: responding to a wage and hour lawsuit in New York.

What to gather this week

Laptop, time card and folder on a desk
  • Every signed hiring notice for the worker or workers named in the complaint, and the date each was signed.
  • Pay stubs or wage statements, and the payroll records behind them, for the whole period the complaint covers.
  • Time records: punch data, schedules, and anything showing the hours actually worked.
  • Any complaint the worker made about pay while employed, and what was done about it.
  • Your payroll company’s name and contact, since they may hold records you don’t.

Don’t call the worker or the worker’s lawyer to talk about the case, and don’t change or “clean up” old records. Records created after a lawsuit are easy to spot and hard to explain.

How The Samuel Law Firm can help

Michael Samuel

Michael Samuel has practiced law in New York since 1993 and has been counsel in more than 500 federal wage and hour cases, most of them for workers. He knows how these complaints are put together, which claims carry real money and which can be challenged early.

When a wage lawsuit comes in, we read the complaint against your payroll and time records, check whether the notice and pay stub claims meet the Guthrie standard, and work out whether the complete-payment defense applies. Then we tell you what a defense looks like and what a realistic resolution looks like, before you decide anything.

Call (212) 563-9884 before your answer deadline. Fees are agreed before you commit, and the first strategy session is free. If you are thinking about settling, read why a judge has to approve most wage settlements.

Frequently asked questions

Up to $5,000 for a missing hiring notice ($50 per work day) and up to $5,000 for missing or improper wage statements ($250 per work day), plus attorney’s fees and costs. That is per worker, and it is separate from any unpaid wages.

No. In 2024 the Second Circuit held that in federal court a worker must plausibly show a concrete harm caused by the missing paperwork. Workers who tie it to a real loss, such as pay stubs that hid unpaid hours, can still recover, and the decision doesn’t govern New York’s state courts.

New York law gives employers a defense to both paperwork claims if the employer made complete and timely payment of all wages due. Whether it applies depends on your payroll and time records, so gather them early.

Yes. Section 195 of the Labor Law applies to every employer in New York, regardless of size. The amounts are the same for a corner restaurant and a large company.

Generally 21 days after service in federal court. In New York State Supreme Court it is generally 20 days if you were handed the papers personally and 30 days if they were served another way. Confirm the date with a lawyer right away.

Talk it through

Free strategy session, fees agreed before you commit

I am Michael Samuel. I have practiced law in New York since 1993 and have been counsel in more than 500 federal wage and hour cases, most of them for workers, so I know how these cases are built from the other side. If your business has been served with a wage lawsuit, the first strategy session costs nothing and you will get a straight answer about where you stand. Fees are agreed before you commit.

For more on how I defend these cases, see my wage and hour defense for employers page.

For a free strategy session, call 212-563-9884, email michael@thesamuellawfirm.com, or use the contact form.

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information about New York law and is not legal advice about your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship.


The Samuel Law Firm

1441 Broadway, Suite 6085

New York, NY 10018

212-563-9884

Contact Us

Sued, owed wages, or injured? Talk to a New York litigator today.

The Samuel Law Firm is a litigation firm in Manhattan. Michael Samuel defends businesses in ADA lawsuits, website and premises, in wage and hour cases, and in contract and commercial disputes, and represents employees owed wages and people injured by negligence. He has practiced in New York since 1993 and appears in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York and the New York state courts. Call 212-563-9884 for a free consultation; he answers directly