Resources

A job description is supposed to be a map of what a worker does each day. Yet in New York City, many employees find their boss asking them to step off the map and take on duties they never agreed to. Sometimes it’s small things, like a cashier asked to sweep the floor before closing. Other times it’s something that changes the entire nature of the job, like an office assistant told to carry heavy construction materials. The question is simple: can employers stretch the scope of employment without paying for it?

What Scope of Employment Really Means

Scope of employment isn’t just legal jargon. It’s the boundary line between what’s reasonable and what’s unfair. A worker hired as a cook may help plate dishes, but that same worker shouldn’t be expected to handle electrical repairs in the kitchen. Courts often ask whether the new tasks are reasonably connected to the original role. If the answer is no, the employer may be crossing a line.

Why Job Descriptions Matter

Think of a job description like a contract handshake written down. It’s not always airtight, but it sets expectations. When disputes arise, that paper trail can become the measuring stick. If new duties look nothing like the original responsibilities, a strong job description gives the worker a clearer argument.

New York Employment Law

At-Will Employment vs. Contracts

Most employees in New York work at-will, which means the employer holds wide authority to change assignments. Yet when a written contract exists, the scope of employment can be locked in tighter. If the contract limits what an employee can be asked to do, it gives that worker leverage if the employer tries to pile on unrelated tasks.

The Implied Contract Exception

Even without a signed deal, courts sometimes recognize an implied contract. Words in an employee handbook, promises made in training, or long-standing company policies can signal that duties are fixed. When that happens, being told to handle jobs outside the description can become a breach of trust — and possibly a breach of law.

Wage and Hour Protections

New York law requires employers to pay for every hour worked — even when the work falls outside the formal job description. Workers who believe they’ve been underpaid should speak with New York wage and hour lawyers about possible claims.

Federal Law

The FLSA Basics

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) sets the floor for wages and overtime. Non-exempt workers must earn minimum wage and time-and-a-half for hours over 40 in a week. If a worker is told to complete extra duties, that time must be tracked and paid.

Exempt or Not?

Exempt workers — often salaried professionals — don’t qualify for overtime. But when extra tasks change the nature of the job, a worker’s exemption may no longer apply. That opens the door to back pay and liability for unpaid overtime.

When Extra Work Crosses the Line

Reasonableness

The law asks: is there a clear connection between the original job and the new tasks? A front desk worker covering housekeeping might be reasonable. Asking that same person to clean hazardous waste? Not so much.

Overtime Triggers

Even small extra duties can push a non-exempt employee over 40 hours — triggering mandatory overtime. Failing to pay turns flexibility into wage theft.

Risks of Reclassification

If you give exempt workers too many new tasks, they may no longer be exempt. That means that employers may owe a lot of unpaid overtime.

Legal Remedies for Employees

In New York, employees have two main paths if scope of duties is abused:

• State claims – File with the NY Department of Labor or bring a lawsuit.
• Federal claims – File with the U.S. DOL or sue under the FLSA.

Either route can lead to recovery of unpaid wages, penalties, and attorney fees.

Real-World Examples

• Restaurant servers ordered to clean grease traps after closing
• Home health aides forced to handle unrelated clerical work
• Retail clerks doing unpaid delivery runs
• Paralegals told to scrub bathrooms

Vulnerability Among Hispanic Workers

In NYC, many Hispanic workers in restaurants, construction, and cleaning are told “other duties as assigned” — often with no extra pay. Language barriers and immigration fears make it harder to speak up. If you suspect wage violations, our Spanish-speaking wage and hour lawyers can help.

Employer Liability

Wage claims aren’t the only risk. If an employee is injured doing unsafe tasks outside their scope, employers may face workers’ compensation or even negligence lawsuits.

Why Local Focus Matters

New York City’s workforce is fast-moving, high-pressure, and filled with hourly jobs where managers often test boundaries. That makes scope-of-employment issues especially common — and risky — here.